I gave the topic of the "Filter Bubble" some thought after I watched this video for one of my Graduate School classes. I thought it made some pretty good points and obviously, from the paragraph above, you can tell I had never given it much thought. Yes, the filter bubble may exist, but is that a bad thing? For some it may be, but for others not so much.
In reference to the "Filter Bubble" he makes statements about the internet being balanced and that that we should not be subjected to what the internet thinks we want to see; that we should be given an aray of information and we should be able to make the choice. I am not going to disagree with this point (quite yet), but this does get me thinking. I mentioned earlier that I had never paid much attention to what the internet shows me when I "Google" or "Bing" something. I think the main reason behind that is because they are showing me what I want to see. I enjoy the fact that "my internet" is tailored to what I want to see. For instance, when it comes to politics, I do not want to read what a liberal mind thinks because, in all honesty, it just gets me frustrated and I'm pretty sure my blood pressure shoots up. I don't mind people that disagree with me and I don't mind having intelligent conversations with people, but when I cannot state my opinion back to someone it just seems like a complete waste of my time. This is where I think the "Filter Bubble" comes in handy; it doesn't give me things that I do not care about seeing. In the video he shows that things have been filtered out on Facebook by TPTB because of certain links that he clicks on. Personally, I have never had that happen to me. He mentions that he did not like it, but I would enjoy some filtering on some occassions. For some reason my Facebook does not know me well enough to know that I am an Auburn fan. If it did I wouldn't have to get on my Facebook and see something related to Alabama on my newsfeed. Filtering, in my opinion, is a good thing because things you don't want to see are not there.
Co-Worker Search |
My Search |
I understand Mr. Pariser's viewpoint, but I just happen to disagree with it. I find that my viewpoint differs from his since he says, "If we are trapped in a filter bubble and not exposed to information that could challenge or broaden our worldview it could prove to be bad for us and our democracy." It is our democracy and the freedom to make our own choices that gives me the ability to disagree with him. I do not feel that my life nor my sense of thought is in jeopardy because I disagree with the use of the "Filter Bubble." I feel that I have all of my thoughts in order and that what I believe is right, so I do not need to be swayed one way or another by some search engine that wants me to become more "worldly" by showing me things that do not relate to anything that I search for. I do not want my Google search randomnly popping up things about different religions because I put in a search for christianity. My opinion of the whole thing: If I wanted to search for it, then I would search for it. Just like he thinks that we should not be subjected to things that Google thinks we should see, which in turn makes it things we want to see; I do not think we should be subjected to seeing things we do not want to see.
Maggie, your comments remind me of what I experience a lot on Facebook. I am also an Auburn fan/grad who loves to see what other fans post around A-Day or during football season or when someone posts a good response to the endless criticism that Auburn football inspires from Alabama fans. However, I am also politically progressive, so I would be one of those folks who would probably post things that would irritate you because it might go against your worldview. I've found myself dividing my Facebook friends into Lists such as "Bama" or "conservative" so that I can cater my message in a way that filters them out. The TED video you are referring to seems to suggest Facebook already helps me out in that regard. I do agree with you that filtering results can be a good thing. Modern life is so busy, it helps to have a shorthand to cut right to the chase of what I actually want. I'm particularly happy with the algorithm that generates advertisements about products I'd actually want rather than nonsense. But I also see the point of the guy in the video. Our perception of reality can rely on the information we are exposed to. That's why I read the Drudge Report AND The Huffington Post. Some of the things on Drudge might get my blood boiling, but the truth may lay in the middle of what those two news sources are sharing. Critical thinking skills are in rare supply these days, and I welcome the opportunity to walk a mile in someone's shoes if it helps me to become a deeper, more empathetic human being. I'm sure there are scientists studying the filter bubble who will have fascinating results of a long-term study of the impact. For now, merely being aware that the filter bubble exists may be enough to cause us pause and reflection.
ReplyDelete